Thursday, March 18, 2010

Biosolid's not waste afterall

Biosolids aka recycled human waste are organic and rich in nutrients. Therefore they are able to work as fertilizer in order to maintain productive soils and stimulate plant growth. Recycling biosolids is when human waste is treated to benefit the growth of agricultural crops, gardens and parks. Biosolids are recycled by farmers and gardeners to help fertilize their farms and gardens. Most of Canada's provinces and territories use the process of recycling biosolids. The use of recycling biosolids comes with both its pros and cons.

PROS

We already know that biosolids are used as valuable fertilizer. Therefore, instead of taking up extra space in a landfill site or disposal facility, they can be put to much better use rather than having its fertilizer capability go to waste. Biosolids are used on farms and in gardens because applying biosolids reduces the need to apply chemical fertilizers. Chemical fertilizers are not the best option because excess applications of them tend to travel into groundwater, streams, lakes and eventually oceans thanks to the rain and irrigation. This results in p
ollution and damage to the natural environment. By using biosolids for agricultural use of crops, it has been found that they meet quality criteria and help to produce significant improvements when it comes to crop growth as well as yield.

Of course, biosolids contain many nutrients which exhibits the reason for their benefits as a fertilizer. These nutrients include nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium. They also contain elements which include calcium, copper, iron, magnesium, manganese, sulfur and zinc. All these nutrients and elements are helpful towards the growth and production of agriculture. Biosolids also reduce costs for farmers. Their production costs decrease and organic matter which has been depleted over time can be replenished thanks to biosolids. It increases the ability of soil to absorb and store moisture, therefore, strengthening its soil structure. Biosolids are used by crops efficiently. This is because the plant nutrients which biosolids contain are slowly released throughout the growing season, enabling crops to absorb these plant nutrients easily during growth.

Biosolids are also able to reestablish vegetation at mine sites. The organic matter and nutrients in biosolids reduce the bioavailability of toxic substances as well as regenerate soil layer. Biosolids can even be used to benefit forestry. Timber is a very important natural resource. They increase timber growth enabling more efficient harvests. Biosolids can be composted, sold and distributed. These composted biosolids can be used for lawns and gardens in homes and are easy to use.

An estimated 50% of all biosolids are recycled to land. As produced in a report in 2001 by the Water Environment Association of Ontario, it has been stated that biosolids are safe, conservative and do not show any significant risk to the environment or the health of humans if practices are followed properly.


CONS

Biosolids, as you might have guessed have a distinctive, smelly odor. They odor depends on the type of treatment it has undergone. Biosolids can smell only slightly disturbing or smell strongly disgusting to people. This odour is mostly caused by compounds of plant nutrients sulfur and ammonia. Though the smell can be reduced through management techniques, you cannot get rid of it completely and weather conditions can spread the odor.

Another disadvantage of biosolids is metals. Many metals may be essential for plant growth, however, there is a concern that large quantities of them can create problems for plants and animals. Therefore, the 503 regulations placed limitations on the amounts of metal which can be used for land application. These limits were created based on the lowest amount of a metal that would create a health problems for humans, plants and animals.

Too much of anything is not good. Over application of fertilizer nutrients can cause problems. For example, if the soil cannot store all of the nutrients, excess nitrogen or phosphorous can be absorbed by the surface/ground water. Over applications of nitrogen can lead to high nitrate concentrations in plants which can kill animals that eat it. However, nutrient management plans can help to use biosolids with other fertilizers to prevent this.

Pathogens (disease-producing agents) are a concern as well.
However, there's a solution to those as well. Some biosolids are extensively treated to make sure there are no pathogens. Other biosolids are treated to reduce pathogen levels as well as well as they are to be used with soil to mix it up.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Therefore, my take on biosolids is that they are good for our soils, even though they come with risks because after all, they are just RISKS and CONCERNS. Even though there are cons in the first place, they all have ways to reduce the potential to harm humans, plants and animals. Plus, biosolids have the ability to enhance plant growth, add nutrients to soil and restore mine sites instead of taking up extra space at a landfill site.

The stakeholders in this issue are the farmers, gardeners and the rest of us. Farmers decide whether they want to use biosolids for their crops and soil or not. Gardeners decide the same thing when it comes to their plants and the rest of us decide the same when it comes to our lawns since biosolids are safe to use. The choice is our own :)


Sources:

http://www.cwwa.ca/faqbiosolids_e.asp

http://www.your-healthy-gardens.com/fertilizers.html

http://pubs.ext.vt.edu/452/452-304/452-304.html

http://pubs.caes.uga.edu/caespubs/pubs/PDF/SB27.pdf




18 comments:

  1. Hey Amanda!
    Looks like I'm the first to comment on your blog! Your LAST blog! Aren't you relived? I know I am :)
    Congrats!

    One thing that REALLY stood out in your bioblog was the fact that you had headings. These heading really assisted in the organization of your blog and shows that you can clearly organize your ideas well. I also noticed that you answered all the questions that were asked in the unit guide. Many people have a great blog, which are very informative but they don't answer the required questions. This shows that you paid great attention to what is expected. You'll probably get perfect for this bioblog !

    I found not grammatical errors in your blog and liked how all your ideas flowed together.
    Great Job Amanda!

    ReplyDelete
  2. u went all out on the last blog! so much information i didn't even know there was so much stuff about my "bio-solids".it seemed like there was more pros than cons to me,we should totally use bio-solids as fertilizers, i don't mind the smell, then again only the farmers would smell it :\

    ReplyDelete
  3. YOOO AMANDUH

    Its my turn to comment on your blog! YOUR BLOG HAS SO MUCH INFORMATION! I didn't know that biosolids are able to reestablish vegetation at mine sites, thats pretty interesting. You also mentioned some negative aspects of biosolids and yet you are still for biosolids. I agree with you completely, we can always find solutions to solve the health hazards and take safety precautions. Even though you said, "they are just RISKS and CONCERNS", I dont think we should just take it lightly because taking those risks and concerns might result to disaster. So, better safe than sorry right?

    ReplyDelete
  4. AMANDA PHEN :)
    I always like your bio blogs! This one has so much information, it can be in an encyclopedia. I like how your bio blog has a lot of detailed information. You stated the pros and cons very well, and just like what Rosemary said, I like how you answered all of the questions. I agree with you completely about using biosolids as an alternative to chemical fertilizer. Even though biosolids can be harmful if not treated properly, they are doing the earth good because they are not in landfills. I think that the use of biosolids has to be extremely regulated. Even though it seems like a very good thing to use (since it helps the environment), biosolids are HUMAN WASTES, so we have to really take the risks into consideration, if we're planning to use them on agricultural land. Overall, I like your blog, so nice and neat. Unlike mine!
    baaai amanda phen

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree that the use of biosolids are RISKS and CONCERNS. Nothing in this world is perfect, like the famous cliche tells us. Everythings has its cons and pros. Biosolids are no exception, especially in the western world, where people turned it into a very controversial subject with endless debates. I think that this debate can be beneficial because it pushes people to do more research on this subject and to further develop the use of biosolids.
    Good job on you post.

    ReplyDelete
  6. with all these virtual gardens and farms like farmville i'm surprised scientists are still trying to give people new ways to improve their garden. well your bioblog was a real treat to read, took me awhile to get through it but i believe you had some excellent pros and cons. i like how you concluded by saying that it is our own choice, i totally forgot that we had a choice to do this so thank you for reminding me.

    if i had a garden i think i would use biosolids, i would learn how to make my own biosolids so that i wouldnt have to pay for my own because we all know that, everybody poops. and it could save us alot of money because we pay for water (which i stil diagee with), we save the environment (indirectly) and it helps our plants, which is what we all want.

    anyways thanks for the time killer, it was very enjouable to read.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi Amanda Phen! =D I really like your last blog. You went into so much detail listing the pros and cons. I really like the picture of the plant with the different compounds. I thought that was a really effective visual aid. I checked out on of your links, the one with the chart about 503 regulations. I really liked that one because I never knew there were so many pathways that a biosolid can come back to us. Anyways, so proud that you've finished! Great job on a final blog! :)

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hey great information. Lots more than my blog ...
    Anyway I like how you segregated your pros and cons, and more pictures are always better! Although even after doing research I dont feel i know all there is to know about the topic, i must say I agree with you; you make a persuasive argument.
    by the by, the juggernaut is mark dalope 9 i saw he posted on your blog)
    anyway, it looks like you went out with a band and kept it positive. great job.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hey, I don't know you but you're like the only other person I could find who did this blog through randomly clicking through names before I got lazy. Hah.

    Anyways, it looks like you pretty much covered all of the pros and cons, so I agree with all of that. It doesn't look like you really left anything out at all actually. I agree with the fact that the cons aren't really huge concerns and that there are ways around them if they ever do become a big concern. I point I didn't think of that I agree with you on is that the biosolids being used as fertilizer also frees up landfill space, which is a big plus since landfill space is already kind of a problem.

    Overall, great job.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hey Amanda!

    I must say that you've covered probably everything there is to know about biosolids. I could use this as a source for my own blog but yeah..i'd most likely get in trouble..LOL.
    Anyways, i'd have to agree that biosolids should be used more often and strictly regulated as it's not something you should handle with carelessness. Besides that, I really do support the use of this fertilizer because as you said, it's organic and helps to maintain soils and stimulates the production of plant growth which is something our earth needs more of right? (:

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hey amanda I thought your bio blog held to its reputation of being right to the point and neatly organized. I liked the headings and I think that the cons are true and that the world can find ways around them. Why should they have to though? You don't have to repair something that isn't broken so why bother with the risks and health concerns that come with biosolids. They are health concerns and risks for the reason that they are deadly and cost the most in life, which is life itself. Anyways I thought you did a great job and I enjoyed reading your blogs all year. Bye Amanda.

    ReplyDelete
  12. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Dearest Amanda,
    As usual, your blog was very insightful and informative. I definitely agree with your pros and cons of biosolids, especially because using them is recycling waste which is either put into a landfill or incinerated if not used as fertilizer. However, I think the risk of possible pathogens being released from biosolids is a risk I would not take, as they are hazardous to health. The use of biosolids as fertilizers are bittersweet. I enjoyed reading your blog.
    Fantastic Job!
    -Priscilla

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hey Phen,

    Great bio-blog once again! I really liked how you made it clear on the pros and cons. Although you could have increased your list of pros on cons, focusing on a few allows you to go more in-depth. I agree that biosolids have amazing potential and it would be a definite waste if we just dump it in a land fill or in the sea, which would probably do more bad than good. Recycling biosolids would be the best option! Of course such an amazing alternative would come with it's risks, but like you I believe that it is imperative that we cast that aside to do what is more BENEFICIAL.

    ReplyDelete